Life Cycle Assessment as an evaluation tool- A critical review on carbon footprint in dairy sector: Carbon footprint of milk

Gokul Tamilselvan; Nitin Tyagi

doi:10.62310/liab.v4i1.131

Authors

Gokul Tamilselvan ICAR - National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal, India https://orcid.org/0009-0006-8286-9077
Nitin Tyagi ICAR - National Dairy Research Institute, Karnal, India

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.62310/liab.v4i1.131

Keywords:

Carbon footprint, Life cycle assessment, Fat and protein corrected milk, Global warming potential, Greenhouse gases, Carbon dioxide equivalents

Abstract

Global warming, a pressing issue affecting countries worldwide, is primarily driven by greenhouse gases emission from various sources including natural disasters and human activities, including industrial processes, agriculture, livestock farming, and the use of fossil fuels. This review specifically addresses the carbon emissions related with dairy farming for milk. While there are several methods available for assessing the dairy carbon footprint, this review concentrates on the widely accepted Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) method recommended mainly by Intergovernmental Panel on Climatic Change. LCA is favoured globally for its comprehensive coverage of the entire product life cycle. The review delves into the application of the LCA method at the farm level, detailing the stages involved in the life cycle assessment. It also provides an in- depth discussion on carbon footprint up to the farm gate level and extends its analysis to encompass the carbon footprint beyond the farm gate for milk production. A significant portion of the review is dedicated in order to elucidate the carbon footprint of dairy cattle and buffalo farming in various countries, drawing insights from diverse research studies worldwide. The focus is primarily on large ruminants, considering that a substantial portion of enteric methane emissions arises from cattle and buffaloes. The review meticulously presents total carbon footprint values for milk production, derived from the cumulative emissions associated with diverse activities involved in the production of milk. This comprehensive examination leads to understanding of the environmental impact of dairy farming and underscores the need for sustainable practices to mitigate the carbon footprint related with milk production globally.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Abin R, Laca A, Laca A, Diaz M. (2018). Environmental assessment of intensive egg production: A Spanish case study. Journal of Cleaner Production 179: 160-168.

Bacenetti J, Bava L, Zucali M, Lovarelli D, Sandrucci A, Tamburini A, Fiala M. (2016). Anaerobic digestion and milking frequency as mitigation strategies of the environmental burden in the milk production system. Science of the Total Environment 539: 450-459.

Batalla I, Knudsen MT, Mogensen L, del Hierro O, Pinto M, Hermansen JE. (2015). Carbon footprint of milk from sheep farming systems in Northern Spain including soil carbon sequestration in grasslands. Journal of Cleaner Production 104: 121-129.

Beauchemin KA, McGeough EJ. (2013). Life Cycle Assessment in Ruminant Production. In: E. Kebreab, editor, Sustainable Animal Agriculture. CAB International, Boston, MA. pp. 212-237.

Belflower JB, Bernard JK, Gattie DK, Hancock DW, Risse LM, Rotz CA. (2012). A case study of the potential environmental impacts of different dairy production systems in Georgia. Agricultural Systems 108: 84-93.

Boehm R, Wilde PE, Ver Ploeg M, Costello C, Cash SB. (2018). A comprehensive life cycle assessment of greenhouse gas emissions from US household food choices. Food Policy 79: 67-76.

Capper JL, Cady RA, Bauman DE. (2009). The environmental impact of dairy production: 1944 compared with 2007. Journal of Animal Science 87(6): 2160-2167.

Casey J, Holden N. (2005). Quantification of GH emissions from sucker-beef production in Ireland. Agricultural Systems 90(1-3): 472-482.

Berton M, Bovolenta S, Corazzin M, Gallo L, Pinterits S, Ramanzin M, Ressi W, Spigarelli C, Zuliani A, Sturaro E. (2021). Environmental impacts of milk production and processing in the Eastern Alps: A “cradle-to-dairy gate” LCA approach. Journal of Cleaner Production 303: 127056. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.127056

Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairying (DAHD) - Final Report. (2023). https://dahd.nic.in/sites/default/filess/FINALREPORT2023ENGLISH.pdf

Dalgaard R, Schmidt J, Flysjo A. (2014). Generic model for calculating carbon footprint of milk using four different life cycle assessment modelling approaches. Journal of Cleaner Production 73: 146-153.

Darre E, Llanos E, Astigarraga L, Cadenazzi M, Picasso V. (2021). Do pasture-based mixed dairy systems with higher milk production have lower environmental impacts? A Uruguayan case study. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 64(3): 444-462.

Del Prado A, Mas K, Pardo G, Gallejones P. (2013). Modelling the interactions between C and N farm balances and GHG emissions from confinement dairy farms in northern Spain. Science of the Total Environment 465: 156-165.

Finnegan W, Yan M, Holden NM, Goggins J. (2018). A review of environmental life cycle assessment studies examining cheese production. The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment 23: 1773-1787.

Flysjo A, Henriksson M, Cederberg C, Ledgard S, Englund JE. (2011). The impact of various parameters on the carbon footprint of milk production in New Zealand and Sweden. Agricultural Systems 104(6): 459-469.

Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2006). https://www.fao.org/3/a0701e/a0701e.pdf

Garg MR, Phondba BT, Sherasia PL, Makkar HP. (2016). Carbon footprint of milk production under smallholder dairying in Anand district of Western India: a cradle-to-farm gate life cycle assessment. Animal Production Science 56(3): 423-436.

Gerber PJ, Hristov AN, Henderson B, Makkar H, Oh J, Lee C, Meinen R, Montes F, Ott T, Firkins J, Rotz A, Dell C, Adesogan AT, Yang WZ, Tricarico JM, Kebreab E, Waghorn G, Dijkstra J, Oosting S. (2013). Technical options for the mitigation of direct methane and nitrous oxide emissions from livestock: a review. Animal 7(2): 220-234.

Gollnow S, Lundie S, Moore AD, McLaren J, van Buuren N, Stahle P, Christie K, Thylmann D, Rehl T. (2014). Carbon footprint of milk production from dairy cows in Australia. International Dairy Journal 37(1): 31-38.

Gonzalez-Quintero R, Kristensen T, Sanchez-Pinzon MS, Bolivar-Vergara DM, Chirinda N, Arango J, Pantevez H, Barahona-Rosales R, Knudsen MT. (2021). Carbon footprint, non-renewable energy and land use of dual-purpose cattle systems in Colombia using a life cycle assessment approach. Livestock Science 244: 104330. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.livsci.2020.104330

Hospido A, Moreira MT, Feijoo G. (2003). Simplified life cycle assessment of Galician milk production. International Dairy Journal 13(10): 783-796.

International Dairy Federation (IDF). (2015). https://www.fil-idf.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/10/201610-IDF-Annual-Report-2015-2016---high-res---web.pdf

International Organization for Standardization (ISO). (2006). ISO 14040 - Environmental management – life cycle assessment – principals and framework. ISO, Geneva, Switzerland.

Jayasundara S, Worden D, Weersink A, Wright T, VanderZaag A, Gordon R, Wagner-Riddle C. (2019). Improving farm profitability also reduces the carbon footprint of milk production in intensive dairy production systems. Journal of Cleaner Production 229: 1018-1028.

Kristensen T, Mogensen L, Knudsen MT, Hermansen JE. (2011). Effect of production system and farming strategy on greenhouse gas emissions from commercial dairy farms in a life cycle approach. Livestock Science 140(1-3): 136-148.

Ledgard SF, Falconer SJ, Abercrombie R, Philip G, Hill JP. (2020). Temporal, spatial, and management variability in the carbon footprint of New Zealand milk. Journal of Dairy Science 103(1): 1031-1046.

Lovarelli D, Bava L, Zucali M, D’Imporzano G, Adani F, Tamburini A, Sandrucci A. (2019). Improvements to dairy farms for environmental sustainability in Grana Padano and Parmigiano Reggiano production systems. Italian Journal of Animal Science 18: 1035–1048.

Mc Geough EJ, Little SM, Janzen HH, McAllister TA, McGinn SM, Beauchemin KA. (2012). Life-cycle assessment of greenhouse gas emissions from dairy production in Eastern Canada: a case study. Journal of Dairy Science 95(9): 5164-5175.

Mech A, Letha Devi G, Sivaram M, Sirohi S, Dhali A, Kolte AP, Malik PK, Veeranna RK, Niketha L, Bhatta R. (2023). Assessment of carbon footprint of milk production and identification of its major determinants in smallholder dairy farms in Karnataka, India. Journal of Dairy Science 106(12): 8847-8860.

Morais TG, Teixeira RF, Rodrigues NR, Domingos T. (2018). Carbon footprint of milk from pasture-based dairy farms in Azores, Portugal. Sustainability 10(10): 3658. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10103658

Noya I, Gonzalez-Garcia S, Bacenetti J, Fiala M, Moreira MT. (2018). Environmental impacts of the cultivation-phase associated with agricultural crops for feed production. Journal of Cleaner Production 172: 3721-3733.

O’Brien D, Brennan P, Humphreys J, Ruane E, Shalloo L. (2014). An appraisal of carbon footprint of milk from commercial grass-based dairy farms in Ireland according to a certified life cycle assessment methodology. The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment 19: 1469-1481.

O’Brien D, Geoghegan A, McNamara K, Shalloo L. (2016). How can grass-based dairy farmers reduce the carbon footprint of milk?. Animal Production Science 56(3): 495-500.

Pirlo G, Terzano G, Pacelli C, Abeni F, Care S. (2014). Carbon footprint of milk produced at Italian buffalo farms. Livestock science 161: 176-184.

Rojas-Downing MM, Nejadhashemi AP, Harrigan T, Woznicki SA. (2017). Climate change and livestock: Impacts, adaptation, and mitigation. Climate Risk Management 16: 145-163.

Roos S, Zamani B, Sandin G, Peters GM, Svanstrom M. (2016). A life cycle assessment (LCA)-based approach to guiding an industry sector towards sustainability: the case of the Swedish apparel sector. Journal of Cleaner Production 133: 691–700.

Rotz CA, Veith TL. (2013). Integration of air and water quality issues. In: Kebreab E, editor, Sustainable Animal Agriculture. CAB International, Oxfordshire, UK. Pp. 137-156.

Rotz A, Stout R, Leytem A, Feyereisen G, Waldrip H, Thoma G, Holly M, Bjorneberg D, Baker J, Vadas P, Kleinman P. (2021). Environmental assessment of United States dairy farms. Journal of Cleaner Production 315: 128153. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2021.128153

Sejian V, Prasadh RS, Lees AM, Lees JC, Al-Hosni YA, Sullivan ML, Gaughan JB. (2018). Assessment of the carbon footprint of four commercial dairy production systems in Australia using an integrated farm system model. Carbon Management 9(1): 57-70.

Singhal KK, Mohini M, Jha AK, Gupta PK. (2005). Methane emission estimates from enteric fermentation in Indian livestock: Dry matter intake approach. Current Science 88(1): 119-127.

Thoma G, Popp J, Nutter D, Shonnard D, Ulrich R, Matlock M, Kim DS, Neiderman Z, Kemper N, East C, Adom F. (2013). Greenhouse gas emissions from milk production and consumption in the United States: A cradle-to-grave life cycle assessment circa 2008. International Dairy Journal 31: S3-S14.

Thomassen MA, van Calker KJ, Smits MC, Iepema GL, de Boer IJ. (2008). Life cycle assessment of conventional and organic milk production in the Netherlands. Agricultural Systems 96(1): 95-107.

Vasilaki V, Katsou E, Ponsa S, Colon J. (2016). Water and carbon footprint of selected dairy products: A case study in Catalonia. Journal of Cleaner Production 139: 504-516.

Wang X, Ledgard S, Luo J, Guo Y, Zhao Z, Guo L, ... & Ma, L. (2018). Environmental impacts and resource use of milk production on the North China Plain, based on life cycle assessment. Science of the Total Environment 625: 486-495.

Weiler V, Udo HM, Viets T, Crane TA, De Boer IJ. (2014). Handling multi-functionality of livestock in a life cycle assessment: the case of smallholder dairying in Kenya. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 8: 29-38.

Wilkes A, Wassie S, Fraval S, van Dijk S. (2020). Variation in the carbon footprint of milk production on smallholder dairy farms in central Kenya. Journal of Cleaner Production 265: 121780. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.121780

Xu X, Lan Y. (2016). A comparative study on carbon footprints between plant-and animal-based foods in China. Journal of Cleaner Production 112: 2581-2592.

Yan MJ, Humphreys J, Holden NM. (2013). Life cycle assessment of milk production from commercial dairy farms: the influence of management tactics. Journal of Dairy Science 96(7): 4112-4124.